From cultivator points to racing engines, gun barrels to hitch pins, subjecting metal parts to extreme sub-zero temperatures is catching on fast as a way to increase useful life.
Cyrogenic processing of steel involves using liquid nitrogen to lower the temperature of parts to -320° F.
But don’t try this at home, experts warn. For the treatment to be effective, it must be done as part of a controlled process.
“You can’t just immerse a piece of steel in a tank of liquid nitrogen,” says Rick Diekman, Controlled Thermal Processing, Inc., Streamwood, Illinois. He says that although cryogenic processing is starting to catch on for agricultural equipment, the majority of the company’s customers are motor sport enthusiasts. A cryogenically treated race car transmission, for example, will last two to three times as long as an untreated one.
“That’s typical,” says Diekman, noting that cryogenic processing normally doubles product life.
Les Baych, Dave Snyder and Bruce Melick opened Cryogenic Engineering, Inc., in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, last year. The three formerly worked for Midland Forge. Baych says they got into the business after sending out parts for cryogenic processing. A die that was normally good for 7,000 pieces lasted through 193,000 pieces after treatment.
Seeing the potential, the three contacted “300 Below”, a Decatur, Illinois, company that sells cryogenic equipment. They bought what they needed and set up shop.
Diekman says a New England knife manufacturer pioneered the idea of cryogenic processing nearly 60 years ago. It was later refined by Applied Cryogenics, a Waltham, Mass., company which developed equipment that it now sells to other companies.
Diekman says the process is just beginning to be used for agricultural equipment like cultivator chisel points.
In cryogenic processing, the temperature of the item to be treated is lowered to at least -300 degrees F.
“It is very important that the temperature of an object be brought down at a controlled rate that is compatible with the temperature is dropped to -320 degrees F over a period of 8 hours or so. The temperature is dropped by allowing liquid nitrogen to enter a heat exchanger that cools the air in the chamber,” he says. Liquid nitrogen is never allowed to actually touch the parts being treated.
Once the temperature in the treatment chamber has reached -320 degrees F, it is held there for at least 6 hours. Some items, however, may be held at the low temperature for as long as 36 hours.
“It depends on the materials being processed,” Diekman says.
After the part has been at -320 degrees F for the proper length of time, the machine then brings it back to ambient temperature, again very slowly to avoid damaging it. Most materials require an additional tempering process. The cryogenic processing machines Diekman uses can continue warming the parts inside up to +300 degrees F. and then cool them again at a controlled rate.
“In some cases, this tempering cycle is repeated a second or even a third time. Again, the rate of change of temperature is rigidly controlled during each cycle,” he says.
“This is much more effective than the rapid heat and quench process alone that some use to temper steel.”
The cryogenic process works on all types of steel and most other commonly used metals. Some sources say steel needs to have doesn’t benefit from treatment, while Diekman has conducted studies that suggest otherwise. Harder type 400 stainless steel does respond, as do most other metals, such as brass (musical instruments), copper, aluminum alloys and some, but not all, cast iron. In addition, some plastics also benefit from cryogenic processing.
Baych says they’ve approached manufacturers about cryogenic treatment of wear parts on farm equipment, but with few successes.
“Manufacturers have an interest in selling parts, so anything that would make them last longer might not be in their best interests,” Baych theorizes.
Cryogenics Engineering says they’ve found that the process adds life to non-steel items too. They’ve even tried it on panty hose.
“If you have something you’d like to process, call us,” Baych says.
“If we’ve had experience with it, we’ll tell you what you can expect from the process. If we haven’t had experience with it, we might try it anyway, particularly if we can then run tests to compare the results with identical untreated items.”
Cost of cryogenic processing is usually based on the weight of the material being processed. Prices start at $6 and $10 per pound and may go down with increased volumes.
Where To Get Cryogenic Processing do cryogenic processing of parts: Applied Cryogenics, Inc. Contact: Jeff Levine 15 Wall Street Waltham, Mass. 02153 ph 781 642-7860 www.huron.org/cryogenic [email protected] 300 Below 2101 E. Olive St. Decatur, Ill. 62526 ph 217 423-3070 Fax 217 423-3075 www.300below.com American Cryogenics,Inc. 305 Travis Lane Waukesha, Wis. 53186 USA ph 414 513-0486 fax 414 513-0485 e-mail: [email protected] http://www.americancryogenics.com Controlled Thermal Processing, Inc. Contact: Rick Diekman 1521 Bourbon Parkway Streamwood, Ill. 60107 ph 630 540-1510 www.metal-wear.com Cryogenic Engineering, Inc. Contact: Les Baych 1131 Wenig Road NE Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52402 ph 319 861-3343 www.cryoeng.com Motion Improvements Contact: Leo Fortey 276 Ayr Road Paris, Ont. N3L 3E2 ph 519 861-6611 www.motion.fortey.net/
Reproduced from the published FARM SHOW entry. Prices, coupons, availability and contact details are historical, not current offers. Reader methods are not universal instructions: follow manufacturer guidance, proper supports and safety practices, and consult a qualified professional when needed.
Comments and votes
Have you tried this idea? Mark it helpful and share how it worked in your shop.